Abortion debate. Should it be the mothers choice?


  • 14
    For Sure!

  • 3
    Maybe

  • 8
    No Way!

Should abortion be the mothers choice?

For SureMaybeNo Way
Who do we protect?  The mom or the baby?

Who do we protect? The mom or the baby?

Do parents have the right to choose?   If a mom is not legally allowed to abort, then who should pay to raise the child?  What is the mom does not want to risk medical complications?  What is the father is not around to help raise the child?  Does the unborn baby have rights?  What is the mother simply does not want to bear a child?

There are so many questions and even more reasons for or against abortion.    Some of the things to keep in mind is that perhaps someone should look out for the unborn child, but also we have to look out for the mother.  The problem is that having the child’s and mom best interests in mind will conflict with each other.  When there is a conflict there truly can only be one side we should support.  We can either protect the baby that has yet to come into this world or the mother/family that is already here.

Morals and ethics can always be murky as they sometimes are based on ones personal feelings.  So then we all have the difficult task to determine who ultimately should have the decision over abortion, the law or the parent.

On one side if we do not give the baby a chance then some people would claim the unborn child was murdered.  All life is precious and it is up to us to govern ourselves to ensure we protect those that can not look out for themselves.

On the other hand, the mom is already here and it is her body.  Should anyone else have the right to tell her what she can or can not do with her own body?  It should be up to the mom to decide as no one should be forced to do something against their will.

So here we are, should abortion be the mother’s choice?   Why do you feel the way you do?

  1. loyal

    # 1 by loyal at May 21st, 2009

    We should all do our best to be protective to those that can protect ourself. But we have to be careful not to force the mom to fo something against her will. After all it is her body and should be her choice.

  2. # 2 by Antoinette at May 21st, 2009

    I am the author of Mamma Called the doctor by Antoinette Romana.

    I was always pro life until I had to face the situation of making a decision to keep or abort my child diagnosed with downs syndrome. I only had 4 days to make this decision and which ever way I chose I knew my life was going to change forever. I was living a dream life with my husband Angelo and my 3 children when I received a shocking phone call from the doctor after my amniocentesis. In my memoir I detail my conversations with family members who backed me with unwavering support and also my dialogue with the doctors and counselors who shared their honest, sometimes emotionless feedback as I along with my husband bravely faced a difficult situation head on with great strength, faith in God and unwavering love for one another. I share my openly honest and heartfelt story of survival with the hope that in reaching out, I will help those who have traveled on the same journey know that they are not alone.

    My book can be purchased at any book websites or can by ordered from any book stores.

    Antoinette

  3. loyal

    # 3 by loyal at May 21st, 2009

    Antoinette is an example of where she should have the final decision. She would know best what is good for her and her family.

  4. # 4 by Moment at May 22nd, 2009

    I think the final choice rests with women, not unborn children. And certainly not with someone who is not involved in the situation. A man who is not the father of the child in question has no damned business telling a woman how she should respond to her pregnancy.
    Yes, the fetus is human. Yes, it will have inviolable human rights someday. But the woman is also human, and she has rights NOW. She has the right to take control of her body, and the fact is that her body entirely encompasses the body of her fetus.
    If pro-lifers really cared about human life (as opposed to controlling women) they would be compelled to aid women who do not want babies to not have babies. As in, they would passionately support birth control and safe sex. They would promote a foster care system where most girls and boys were NOT beaten or sexually abused. They would support more human rights in general. As it is, I cannot help but think that the unborn child’s value to them rests almost entirely upon how they feel they can use it. Also, unless they control and slut shame women, unless they make women know their place in the patriarchy, how will they handle that new society? Pro-lifers tend to be more barefoot-and-pregnant-in-the-kitchen than otherwise, and that makes me lose a lot of respect for them. Their concern for fetuses doesn’t add up the way they’d like it to. And they treat women like shit when they protest women’s health clinics and set up false “pregnancy counsel” clinics.

  5. firefly

    # 5 by firefly at May 22nd, 2009

    Who is going to look after the baby if the mother will not. The mother should not have the right to take the life away. That is too much power for a mom to have.

  6. # 6 by Nancy Bennett at May 25th, 2009

    Yes it needs to be a mother’s choice. With correct medical knowledge she will make a wise decision and be able to live with it.
    My Dad saved my life. My Mother was 3 months pregnanct when she found out she was carrying their fourth child. Right away my Grandfather told my Mother to get rid of it. My Dad knew about Grama’s abortions to get rid of siblings. She was forced to abort the others. There was just him & his sister. My Dad told Granddad, “There will be none of that in this house.” I am so thankful for my wonderful Dad. My parents had 2 more children after me. We are a loving family, and I can not imagine not having my 5 terrific siblings.
    To the Men: Men, stand up and protect your wife and children. When you see women who are depressed, alcoholic, angry and suicidal,
    it just may be she has been forced to have an abortion. She will suffer no matter if she was forced to make the choice or chose to make that choice herself to abort. She will likely still go through the post traumatic syndrome, unable to forgive herself. It is not easy for her. I was very upset when I learned I was 3 months pregnant. We were married just 3 months, and I wanted to work for 5 years. I phoned my husband and cried on the phone and said I’m pregnant. He said, it’s okay, everything will be okay, don’t worry about it.
    I had been x-rayed for a kidney infection, and they saw the baby. For one month I did not want that baby. On the 4th month, everything changed. The baby moved. It was real to me.
    Now I wanted that baby. I could hardly wait to see this baby and be a mother. Thank goodness I did not have a Dr. who rushed me in to get rid of it. How beautiful is my son, who is now a grown man with two little children of their own. I asked him if he had ever felt rejection from me. He said “No, Mom, on the contrary, I have always felt great love and care from you.” I told him why I had asked that. His wife said, “See ? A Lot of women feel that way, till the baby moves and changes our mind.” I am so glad, so relieved that I didn’t take the first instinct, thought to get rid of ‘it’. Now he is a high school counsellor and a wonderful son, a great Dad, and husband to his wife. I am truly thankful, that I do not agree with abortion. I have seen too many women suffer from abortion.

  7. MoonGoat

    # 7 by MoonGoat at May 25th, 2009

    Parents get to decide what happens - period. Hell I think they should have the right to abort their kid if he’s 12 and burning down the neighbour’s garage for kicks on the weekend.

    Bottom line is IT’S NOT ALIVE - it’s tissue, a growth - a blob, if you will. If the blob is not wanted then they visit the clinic and the woman gets the blob taken out. No big deal.

    Y’know, it’s the old saying, if men carried babies, we wouldn’t even be discussing this. IDK how chicks have put up with this nonsense for so long. Knock it off.

  8. # 8 by ruffneck at May 26th, 2009

    You and only yourself have the right to decide and control your own body.

  9. # 9 by shane st. croix at June 2nd, 2009

    The choice should be not to get pregnant .

  10. # 10 by shane st. croix at June 2nd, 2009

    Hey moon goat…the only blob appears to be between your ears…human sperm and human egg create human life…dah !

  11. # 11 by bjanna at June 3rd, 2009

    shane st. croix :The choice should be not to get pregnant .

    Tell that to the 11 year old who is raped by her father.

  12. # 12 by becky at June 19th, 2009

    yehh the woman does have rights.. if this is so she has the right to take contraception to stop herself gettin pregnant in the 1st place.
    think of all those poor people out ther who cant have kids. most people have abortions for selfish reasons such as they dont have “enough money” and lets be honest who really has enough money to care for a baby these days.
    im only 17 and i kno my mother would want me to abort a child if i fell pregnant but it would be my choice nobody else could make you do anything!
    ONLY IN EXTREME circumstances should it be allowed to happen such as rape, insest or if there is a high risk of the mother or babies health being critically damaged!


Register your account or Login. This will let you pick a side by voting.

(will not be published)

  1. No trackbacks yet.